Initiators To Make Sevan A Fish Farm Didn’t Convince Environmentalists

Initiators To Make Sevan A Fish Farm Didn’t Convince Environmentalists

EcoLur

Lake Sevan, a strategic object for Armenia, is again targeted, this time it’s about “Complex Program for Recovery of Trout Reserves and Fish Breeding in Lake Sevan”, which is currently undergoing environmental expertise. The project is submitted by “Armenian Harvest Promotion Center” CJSC caused a wave of protests among environmentalists and public at large. Under the project, it’s planned to make the production of the trout up to 50,000 tons in the lake up to 2023 in the nurse ponds, where annually 50,000 tons of artificial forage will be thrown into the lake, while it contains nitrogen and phosphorus. Only 1.5% of the bred trout will be left in the lake, while the rest will be exported.

Another discussion of this project was held at Yerevan Aarhus Center on 16 January. The project was presented by Edvard Gevorgyan from “Armenian Harvest Promotion Center” CJSC. He noted that the aim of this project is not business interests, but the recovery of the trout reserves in Lake Sevan, that’s why the project is called environmental. In regard with nitrogen and phosphorus available in the artificial forage, he said, “When we will make the production up to 50,000 tons, only 532 tons of nitrogen and 45-126 tons of phosphorus will be collected in the lake. But today we have 400 tons of phosphorus and 700 tons of nitrogen getting into the Lake Sevan. If we can perform compensation mechanisms through the project and will remove sewage water from the lake, we will take 400 tons of phosphorus out of the lake versus 126 tons.”

The environmentalists don’t agree with such an approach. In their opinion, the project completely contradicts to RA Law “On Lake Sevan” and can’t be named as an environmental one. “The project can’t be called environmental, as it contains ecological risks. All environmental measures should be directed at river cleaning and freeing space for fish spawning. Cleaning water is an environmental project, while they say let’s pollute the water, it’s already polluted,” said “EcoLur” Informational NGO President.

“50,000 tons is a terrible figure. Even if the project contains non-proved risks, we are not entitled to any actions. Sevan is everything: if we lose Sevan, we will lose Armenia,” said Yelena Manvelyan, Chairman of “Armenian Women for Health and Healthy Environment” NGO. Lilik Simonyan noted, if the water is clean, the trout is capable of self-recovery, “The trout should spawn in the rivers, while the rivers are currently blocked with SHPPs. We should remove the cause o pollution in Sevan, to clean it, then the fish will be able of recovering on its own,” she noted.

During the discussions “Sevan” National Park SNCO Deputy Director in Science Vahe Ghulanyan presented the findings of the studies carried out by the national park: “We selected four observation sites near nurse ponds and reference points for the studies in Lake Sevan. The obtained data are quite reassuring, we didn’t record any data exceeding the permissible standards.”

"The fact that the results of our studies didn’t show anything negative, doesn’t mean anything. The strategic priority for us is not only to have clean water, but also fish. I am for the launch of the project, but I oppose to the scales of this project. Things are bad with 500 ha. The works should be carried out, but a strict monitoring should be performed in parallel with it. Then, if we can see any threat is available, the project must immediately be stopped. The project must clearly lay down, “to stop the project, in case minimum threat is available,” said Evelina Ghukasyan, Director of Hydroecology and Ichthyology Institute of NAS RA.

January 20, 2014 at 14:19