Public Disagree with World Bank Policy in Forest Sector

Public Disagree with World Bank Policy in Forest Sector

EcoLur

The World Bank disseminated information about the results of the meeting with ENPI-FLEG representatives with the public which was held on 12 April.

The social networks record the participants’ responds that witness this information doesn’t reflect the public position to WB policy in the forest sector of Armenia.

International ENPI-FLEG program aimed its fight against illegal felling and making reforms in forest sector, which is implemented in six countries, including Armenia. ENPI-FLEG program partners are the World Bank, IUCN and WWF. The meeting was held by public request and was participated by ENPI-FLEG Program Manager Andrew Mitchell, World Bank Consultant Nils Junge, ENPI-FLEG Coordinator from the World Bank in Armenia Artavazd Hakobyan, as well as civic society representatives Nazel Vardanyan – “Forests of Armenia” NGO, Hakob Sanasaryan – Greens Union of Armenia, Aida Iskoyan – the Center for Environmental Law, Dolores Kapantsyan – “For Sustainable Human Development” Association, Hasmik Aslanyan – “Shogher” Association, Gohar Ghazinyan - OSCE office in Yerevan, Mariam Sukhudyan - youth green movement activist and Inga Zarafyan – EcoLur Informational NGO.

The main contradiction in the position between public and the World Bank is that WB is only concerned with the problem of illegal felling and nature management tax evasion. Meanwhile the WB thinks the problem will be solved if to minimize tax evasion to a real extent.

Nevertheless, people believe the main task is not to allow forest destruction, which have exclusively protective function in Armenia and not forests of industrial significance. Consequently such mechanisms should be worked out that will allow to take into consideration the needs of people who have to use forest as fuel, but not to allow forest destruction for business purposes.

People are not satisfied with the fact that WB considers environment as potential resources. Andrew Mitchell outlined: “We act in a manner so as to have sustainable forest management. It’s impossible for us to follow any other policy but sustainable management. And we wonder if there any problems that promote non-sustainable management of illegal felling.”

Certainly there are problems: fight against illegal felling in Armenia acquires strange nature. On one hand, punishment measures are made tougher – fines are so high that a forestry officer responsible for forest preservation can lose his annual salary for several cut down trees, or to bear responsibility for under the Criminal Code of Armenia. On the other hand, each year the government reduces the funding of “ArmForest” SNCO from the state budget, while “ArmForest” secures its existence at the expense of forest sale.

May 27, 2011 at 11:05