

Inga Zarafyan, EcoLur
One-kilometer-long (or two) tunnel dug through the mountains leads us to the bunker. The bunker itself goes underground to the depth of at least 150 meters. What is it? This is future waste burial for radioactive and hazardous chemical wastes, the place the Center for Geological-Exploring Investigations of Yerevan State University is searching for. The Center is a contractor implementing the order of the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources of RA. Here is the main intrigue – what must be buried in a waste burial ground with such specific parameters? We got some explanations at the working meeting of the initiative group of the Alliance for Environmental NGOs held at the Aarhus Center in Yerevan on 7 June. Participants were as follows: “Armenian Women for Health and Healthy Environment” NGO, the Center for Bird Lovers, Environmental Academy, “For Sustainable Human Development” Association, “National Water Partnership”, “EcoLur” Informational NGO, as well as the Director of the Center for Geological-Exploring Investigations Marat Grigoryan (contractor), Head of Chair at Yerevan State University Edik Khorozyan, the representative of the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources of RA Nune Hakobyan and journalists.
Reminder: the topic for discussion is the S.O.S. signal about the disposal of a new waste burial ground for radioactive and hazardous chemical substances and wastes in the territories of Zangakatoun and Ourtsalanj Communities (Ararat Region). In April and May 2 Zangakatoun and Ourtsalanj villagers went to bat against this investigative work. When villagers found out this investigative work to be connected with disposal of a hazardous object, they blocked the road and turned out the contractors. Ararat Regional Head Vardges Hovakimyan invited a meeting where the villagers presented the following substantiations:
-the place for disposal a waste burial ground is located too near their settlement,
-the irrigation aqueduct system of three villages run near the proposed place,
-environmental situation may deteriorate caused by geological-prospecting drilling -works (villagers say that have high radiation background),
-Animal species registered in the Red Book inhabit in this place.
Who needs this waste burial ground?
“The Government adopted a decision to collect all kinds of wastes, both radioactive and chemical, in one place. We selected a safer place free from landslip risks, earthquakes, there are water-bearing layers. Bunkers for all types of wastes should be prepared at the depth of 150 m in order to get permanent place for their disposal and dug through one-kilometer-long tunnel,” said contractor Marat Grigoryan and added this have nothing in common with nuclear station. Under him, the distance between the selected place and the nearest village is 3 km, and he cannot understand why the villagers rebel. “This is a governmental decision and a state priority,” Grigoryan said.
No satisfactory reply was given to Physicist-Hygienist Lilik Simonyan’s question (“Armenian Women for Health and Healthy Environment” NGO) ‘Who needs a new waste burial ground, if we have an operating one in Metsamor?”
Lilik Simonyan reminded that Metsamor waste burial ground was constructed just medicinal and laboratory wastes, while radioactive wastes buried in Sovetashen were also transferred here. “Special radioactive forces dealt with these problems and transferred all to Metsamor. But now medicinal wastes are dumped here. Already now there is a hazardous object next to the waste burial ground for dry radioactive wastes from the nuclear power plant, and we don’t need a new hazardous object, especially when the amount of these wastes is not so huge,” Lilik Simonyan said.
About Regulating Documents
IAEA Guide № 111-G-4.1 (Vienna, 1994)
When asked about the availability of an environmental expert opinion, Marat Grigoryan replied that expert examination will be conducted when the waste burial ground project will exist, but now, no expert examination is required for prospecting stage. Nune Hakobyan supported him and showed IAEA Guide № 111-G-4.1 (Vienna, 1994). As a matter of fact, the guide itself says nothing about the distance from settlements. Nevertheless, Para 3.4 of this Guide says, the process will involve integration of site investigative work from a number of disciplines, one of them identifying type and amount of wastes to be buried.
Government Decision № 836 dated on 23 July 2009
This very definition is lacking in the government decision of conducting geological prospecting (№ 836 dated on 23 July 2009), where the issue of a waste burial ground is examined in Para 6 of its Appendix together with other usual geological prospecting works.
Government Decision № 228 dated on 22 February 2007
As a matter of fact, the regulating document the government decision for 2009 refers to is the government decision № 228 dated on 22 April 2007. It’s entitled “On Establishing Order for Issuing Permits to Conduct Works for Purposes of Investigation, Prospecting, Extraction of Radioactive Raw Materials and Burial of Radioactive Hazardous Chemical Wastes.” This decision has a paragraph about the burial of aforementioned wastes, but nothing about medicinal or laboratory wastes. None of these documents say a word about them.
Government Decision № 234 dated on 6 March 2008
Government Decision № 234 “On Establishing “Armenian-Russian mining Company” CJSC” dated on 6 March 2008 also has a reference to На Government Decision № 228. At present this very company is implementing the uranium program in Armenia.
QUESTIONS LEFT WITHOUT ANSWERS
1. Why didn’t the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA hold public discussions of the government decisions that directly touch upon environmental and health interests in connection with radiation safety?
2. Why didn’t the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA demand to conduct state expert examination in the connection with radioactive waste burial, why didn’t it require primary project?
3. What must be buried in the waste burial ground of such sizes (see above) that must comply not with the requirements of environmental expert examination, but exclusively with International Atomic Energy Agency requirements?
4. Aren’t exploration of uranium reserves or finding an appropriate place for radioactive burial ground components of new nuclear policy that includes not only just the nuclear station?
5. At last, what will happen to us if this policy will be ran in a territory of no more than 29,000 square kilometers?
If to take 2007 year as time reference, we don’t have to wait long.
June 29, 2010
