

EcoLur
Whether small hydropower stations are ecological or not? A round table was held on 3 September dedicated to the issue of hydropower station impact on environment in Armenia. The discussions were initiated by “EcoLur” NGO supported by the Aarhus Centre in Yerevan. Their viewpoints on this issue expressed the specialists of the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA, the Ministry of Power and Natural Resources of RA, the Institute for Hydroecology and Ichthyology, WWF Armenia and business representatives. The number of small hydropower stations is as follows: at present 54 small hydropower stations function in Armenia, and nearly 20 ones in Sevan basin. The tariff for 1 KW of power makes up 18 AMD. The specific weight of small hydropower stations in the overall production of power makes up 2-3%.
The main advantages of small power engineering are as follows: decrease in harmful substance and greenhouse gas emission into atmosphere, exploitation of local sources for power, the interest of small and medium business to this sphere, and the opportunity to use the mechanisms of the Kyoto Protocol that promote to the standardization of small hydropower station performance and compliance to international standards and control exercise.
The main disadvantages of small power engineering are as follows: absence of regulating and controlling mechanisms in the use of water resources. River ecosystems are under thermal and vibration pressure. The local population suffers a shortage of drinking and irrigation water in those sections of the river where small hydropower stations are located. Moreover, the locals do not take part in the decision-making process of small hydropower station construction, though this directly concerns their interests. Littoral forests and other vegetation wither, the fish dies out, and the river ecosystem deteriorates. The current legislation does not permit to evaluate the damage caused by small hydropower stations in an adequate manner, and this fact results in inadequate compensations making up 30-40 USD per year. The total effect of the small hydropower station impact is not estimated.
The participants of the round table made a number of suggestions:
- to terminate the issue of licenses for small hydropower station construction until the complete settlement of the problem in legal sphere,
- to work out a realistic concept for water resources management directed at sustainable development,
- to carry out public monitoring over the present small hydropower stations with the participation of state inspection bodies,
- to review power policy in regard to small hydropower stations, particularly, in regard to tariff making.
Most participants came to the conclusion that public monitoring is needed at high level with the participation of all interested, where a decision should be adopted and submitted to RA Government.
Press publications on the outcomes of the round table are given below.
HYDRO-ELECTRIC STATIONS ARE DANGEROUS
A1+
Small hydro-electric stations are harming the water and thermal regimes of the rivers and creating obstacles for fish reproduction. The construction of the stations causes ecological problems, say participants of the round-table discussion held today at the Orhus center in Yerevan.
According to Head of the Environmental Protection Department of the RA Ministry of Nature Protection Aram Gabrielyan, the small rivers may become a source of energy, but preference must be given to drinking and irrigation water, fishing and then energy production.
There are 60 hydro-electric stations in Armenia, but there are prospects for broadening the business.
Ecologists are also concerned that the stations are not built correctly. As head of the Armenia branch of the World Wilderness Fund Karen Manvelyan told "A1+", the stations are built disproportionately and the water is used without considering what it's used for.
According to Karen Manvelyan, there are two important things-interests of the local population and nature. "The susceptibility of the ecosystem is not taken into account. The trees nearby are eliminated and the population's interets are not taken into account either. People have their lands, cultivate them, receive profits, but all that is eliminated with the construction of the hydro-electric stations."
When Head of the Division of Restoring Energy of the Department of Development at the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources Daniel Stepanyan tried to justify that the stations are put into action after they are examined, Karen Manvelyan opposed: "Nobody can exclude that they are examined, but for some reason, regardless of the issues, they are still passed," said Karen Manvelyan in closing.
NEW THREATS: ENVIRENMENTALISTS ALARM ON THE EFFECT OF MINOR POWER PLANTS ON THE ECOLOGY OF RIVERS IN ARMENIA
Georg Khachaturyan, ArmeniaNow.com
The operation of minor power plants is a serious threat to the ecology of rivers they are built on. according to Aram Gabrielyan, head of the department of environmental protection at the Ministry of Nature Protection, during a Thursday discussions on the issue.
According to him, the construction of small plants in spite of the fact that all the norms and standards are strictly followed does not guarantee unavoidable damage to the river flow.
“The mere fact that river water first gets into the turbine and then only returns to the river is a serious threat to the natural river flow,” stressed Gabrielyan.
Daniel Stepanyan, Head of Renewable Energy Division at the RA Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources, stated that power engineering is one of the most rapidly developing spheres of Armenia’s economy attracting sizable investments. A proper legislative field has been created for the sphere of power plant construction, and, prior to beginning any construction, projects and programs go through ecological examination, eliminating problematic issues potentially harmful for the environment.
However, Karen Manvelyan, office manager of the World Wildlife Fund, stated that favorable results of the environmental examination exist only on paper. In reality when building minor power plants the ecology of rivers suffers huge damage: rivers start shoaling, their banks are turned into garbage dumps, uncontrolled logging of trees starts in the forest zones of river adjacent areas. Before starting the realization of such a project, detailed mapping of the area has to be done, as well as a serious ecological examination.
September 04, 2009
