

EcoLur
On 15 June 2010 the Chairman of Board of Directors of “Gegamet Plus” Company Vladimir Gasparyan, RA NAS Academician Sergey Grigoryan responsible for geological prospecting and company’s other representatives presented their substantiations for this project at the Aarhus Center in Yerevan. In the working meeting the environmental society was presented by “For Sustainable Human Development” Association Chairman Karine Danielyan, “Armenian Women for Health and Healthy Environment” NGO Expert Qnarik Grigoryan, board member of Committee on Agriculture and Nature protection and Director of “Sevan” National Park from 1982-1991 Gagik Sukhudyan, Expert-Hydrologist Qnarik Hovhannisyan and “EcoLur” working group.
The project on processing production was discussed in the course of the working meeting.
We speak about Shorzha and Jil dunite-periodite deposit developed by the abovementioned company for two years already. In November 2008 “Gegamet Plus” CJSC announced about its intention to construct an ore-processing plant in Shorzha. In March 2010 Ecolur working group revealed one building of the plant had already been constructed, while open-cast processing was already in progress. It should be noted that the civil works started without having the opinion provide by the State Environmental Inspection of the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA which rejected the project citing Article 10 of RA Law “On Lake Sevan” banning ore-processing activities in Sevan basin. It should also be noted that neither public representatives nor “Sevan” National park representatives took part in the public discussions in Shorzha held in 28 April.
This information was dissemination via EcoLur hot line and mass media.
On 9 June 2010 National Assembly Deputy Khachik Manukyan, one of the co-owners, told EcoLur this enterprise is ecologically clean and the company is willing to present evidence. Exchange of opinions took place on 15 June.
Company’s main arguments for this project are as follows:
1. This enterprise is not a processing one as here rock is subject to crushing and gravity separation of rock into heavy metal oxides and light rock. Under V. Gasparyan, these processes are not included into processing.
2. This enterprise is waste-free, as entrepreneurs intend to lay Sevan shores with crushed rock as a kind of peculiar filter. According to Academician Grigoryan’s explanations, this rock is quartz with insignificant admixtures of chromium, aluminum and other elements. What is most important is that rock doesn’t contain sulphides promoting chemical pollution of environment. The mine is magmatic, aluminum and chromium oxides are stable, and they don’t dissolve or contain sulphur compounds.
3. RA Law “On Lake Sevan” is not violated as the law bans ore processing, while the mine contains no ore, but rock. Article 10 hereof contains no “rock” word.
4. This enterprise will enable to set up 300 working places, an important social support for the region.
What about already built building and open-cast rock processing, V. Gasparyan assured this is not a factory building, but old equipment merely covered with crimped corridors for trapping dust caused by crushing. What about open-cast processing, according to V. Gasparyan, rock crushing is an old tradition left from experimental enterprise producing fire brick.
Public arguments against this project are as follows:
1. Article 10 of RA Law “On Lake Sevan” banning ore-processing activities in Sevan basin directly refers to this enterprise, as crushing and gravity separation of rock are a part of production stage for processing.
2. The argument this is not an ore, but rock is just a substitution of words, as this article mentions ore-processing activities.
3. The crushed rock the company considers as “an ecological filter” for Sevan may pose a danger to Sevan drainage basin, as it is extracted from natural ecosystem in separation process, and is, as a matter of fact, waste.
4. RA Law “On Lake Sevan” is violated as mine development will destroy Aregouni Mountain, an integral part of the lake ecosystem.
5. The provisions of the European Landscape Convention ratified by Armenia in 2003 are also violated.
6. Independent expert assessment is needed about this project compliance with RA Law “On Specially Protected Territories” (impact zone - “Sevan” National Park), RA Law “On Conserving Flora”, RA Law “On Protecting Fauna”, the UN Biodiversity Convention and the Water Code of RA.
Taking into consideration the national and strategic priority of Lake Sevan ecosystem conservation, as well as non-compliance of “Gegamet Plus” Company’s activities in Sevan basin with national legislation, non-holding of public discussions with set procedures, presence of civil works without any opinion from the State Environmental Inspection, we propose:
- to hold wide-scale public discussions till the consideration of the new documentation package for this project,
- to submit documentation package to independent expert assessment,
- to stop the civil works till the opinion from the State Environmental Inspection of the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA.
Meeting participants Gagik Sukhudyan and Qnarik Hovhannisyan join EcoLur’s enquiry.
July 06, 2010
