20 Years with EBRD: Balance between Sustainable Development and Net Profit

20 Years with EBRD: Balance between Sustainable Development and Net Profit

Karine Manukyan, ArmInfo

This year the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development celebrated the 20th anniversary of its operation. Under the data for 2010, the bank made a net profit of 1,4 billion Euros and implemented record-breaking number of projects  - 386. 

NGO Network in Central and Eastern Europe “Bankwatch” notes many projects implemented by EBRD have created social or environmental problems. Environmentalists are particularly concerned with the loaning of projects submitted metallurgical giants such as “ArcelorMittal Temirtay” (Kazakhstan) and “ArcelorMittal Krivoy Rog” (Ukraine). Green activists point out both companies haven’t fulfilled environmental obligations, nevertheless it didn’t hinder EBRD for positive assessment of project implementation. EBRD participation in mining loaning occurred in Armenia as well; the bank granted Deno Gold Mining Company a loan of US million to construct Geghanoush tailing dump. In 2008 the tailing dump was put into operation, nevertheless, as a result of public monitoring it turned out the main principles of social and environmental responsibility were not adhered to in the project implementation, i.e. the principles declared by the EBRD. According to “EcoLur” NGO, Geghanush villagers were forced to give their land areas for the construction of the tailing dump, but the villagers opposed to this and collected 143 signatures. 

Now Armenian environmentalists are focused on Amoulsar gold-bearing mine. The opencast mine development implemented by Lidian International bears risks not only connected with polluting environment with heavy metals, but also with radiation. The company presented to the public sample analyses where uranium content is minimum and doesn’t exceed 0,0002%. Under EcoLur, this doesn’t contradict to the scientific data submitted in the article by G. P. Aloyan, Dr. in Geological Sciences  (“Горный журнал”, N 6, 2007), but also it doesn’t reflect the picture of uranium distribution in Amoulsar and additional investigations are needed for this purpose. 

In 2009 EBRD became the owner of 8,1% shares of the company. At the same the EBRD official representatives state they don’t know anything about Amoulsar, and the cooperation with the company is conducted in the Balkans and not Armenia. “If the bank were involved in this project, it would be implemented in accordance with highest international standards,” Alistair Clark, EBRD Corporate Director, Environment and Sustainability Department. 

May 31, 2011 at 15:43