PUBLIC SECTOR HAS RIGHT TO BE INFORMED, WHILE STATE SECTOR HAS OBLIGATIONS

PUBLIC SECTOR HAS RIGHT TO BE INFORMED, WHILE STATE SECTOR HAS OBLIGATIONS

EcoLur

Afterword to the discussions at the Aarhus Center in Yerevan

On 18 January the discussion of  “Environmental and Social Profile for Deno Gоld Mining Company’s Operation in Armenia” booklet was held at the Aarhus Center in Yerevan.

Having even not warned the organizer for the discussion “EcoLur” Informational NGO, Head of Informational-Analytical Center of the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA Gagik Hovhannisyan isolated them from running the discussions and submitted its own agenda.  Deno Gold Mining Company representatives, PR Manager Norayr Aghayan and Engineer-Environmentalist Hasmik Mkrtumyan had unlimited time for their speeches.  At the same time  Gagik Hovhannisyan limited the time and assigned to Arthur Ghazaryan only 3 minutes, whereas Arthur Ghazaryan had arrived from Kapan and was the representative of “For Ensuring Ecological Safety and Developing Democracy”, EcoLur’s partner in conducting the public monitoring. Gagik Hovhannisyan abruptly interrupted Arthur Ghazaryan when the latter wanted to clear up the situation in Kapan. Arthur Ghazaryan only managed to say that the whole information submitted for publishing can be substantiated by existing documents (EcoLur has the scanned copies for these documents).

The discussions didn’t appear to be constructive; the essential parts of the booklet needing urgent solutions have not been commented such as:

•    Shahumyan community residents’ complaints forced to bring an action in regard to risks of mine collapses developed by the company,

•    conclusions and recommendations made by GEORISK Scientific-Expert Company, where the company proposes to take urgent measures to decrease threats of collapses in Shahumyan Mine,

•    illegal change in the course of the Norashenik river (Atchanan),

•    the protest of Geghanush Villagers against the construction of Geghanush tailing and their complaints of the environmental pollution by the company which are practically not compensated,

•    contamination of Syunik community with dumps having been left since 2006-2007, when the Artsvanik tailing was developed by the company,

•    dumps on the banks of the Norashenik River leading to the contamination of the land area in Syunik Community,
•    contamination of Kapan and its adjacent territories with dumps containing toxic elements and heavy metals.

•    continual pollution of the Voghji transboundary river.  

We don’t refuse from having a dialogue with official bodies and business sector. We hope that the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA and other ministries and departments, as well as the company itself will realize that the submitted information has a precautionary nature and aims to react to S.O.S. signals from Kapan and adjacent communities about existing risks in order to take measures to reduce them.

What about the discussion itself, we would like to remind Head of Informational-Analytical Center of the Ministry of Nature Protection of RA Gagik Hovhannisyan that the operation of the Aarhus Center is conditioned by the provision of the Aarhus Convention. In accordance with the Aarhus Convention, public has a right to participation in decision making in important environmental matters, while the state sector has obligations, and not the vice versa.

January 29, 2010